Halogenoalkanes

Class 12 Chemistry, unit 9, book pages 171–182

Partial. Printed pages 176 to 179 and 182 of the textbook are not yet covered from the book itself. The notes for these pages (the end of SN1, SN2, alkyl-group effects, elimination, the reactions with KCN, NH3 and OH⁻, and the start of the C–X bond strength section) are written from the unit's learning outcomes and key points, so check them against your textbook. Exercise MCQs i to viii are solved; the rest of the exercise on printed page 182 (any further MCQs and all short and long questions) is still to be added.

Halogenoalkanes () contain a polar C–X bond whose carbon is attacked by nucleophiles. This unit shows how the structure of the halogenoalkane and the reaction conditions decide between , and elimination, and why halogenoarenes such as chlorobenzene are much less reactive. It ends with the C–X bond strength (the silver nitrate test) and with retrosynthesis, which uses halogenoalkanes as starting materials for alcohols, nitriles and amines.

Learning outcomes (7)
  • Describe the reaction of benzene with and in the presence of a catalyst to produce halogenoarenes.
  • Compare the reactivity of a halogenoalkane and a halogenoarene, using chloroethane and chlorobenzene as examples.
  • Predict the major product(s) from the reaction conditions and the molecular structure of the halogenoalkane.
  • Analyse the mechanism and products of a reaction pathway involving a halogenoalkane, and use retrosynthesis to deduce the starting materials.
  • Describe the and mechanisms of nucleophilic substitution in halogenoalkanes, including the effects of alkyl groups.
  • Identify that primary halogenoalkanes tend to react by the mechanism, tertiary halogenoalkanes by the mechanism, and secondary halogenoalkanes by a mixture of the two, depending on structure.
  • Explain the different reactivities of halogenoalkanes, with particular reference to the relative strengths of the C–X bonds, as shown by their reactions with aqueous silver nitrate.

Halogenoalkanes and their classification

A halogenoalkane (alkyl halide) is an alkane in which one hydrogen atom has been replaced by a halogen atom (F, Cl, Br or I). They are also called halogen derivatives of alkanes. The general formula is , where R is an alkyl group and X is the halogen. With one halogen atom on an open chain the molecular formula is .

When the halogen is bonded directly to a benzene ring the compound is a halogenoarene (aryl halide), general formula , where Ar is an aryl (arene) group. Chlorobenzene is the simplest example. Halogenoarenes behave very differently from halogenoalkanes (section 9.2).

Primary, secondary and tertiary halogenoalkanes

Halogenoalkanes are classified by the carbon atom that carries the halogen. Count how many other carbon atoms (alkyl groups) are bonded to that carbon.

TypeCarbon carrying X is bonded toExamples
Primary (1°)one other carbon atom (or none, as in chloromethane)chloromethane , chloroethane , 1-chloropropane
Secondary (2°)two other carbon atoms2-chloropropane , 2-chlorobutane
Tertiary (3°)three other carbon atoms2-chloro-2-methylpropane (tert-butyl chloride)
chloroethane (1°)
2-chloropropane (2°)
2-chlorobutane (2°)
2-chloro-2-methylpropane (3°)

Physical properties

Halogenoalkanes have higher melting and boiling points than alkanes of similar size. The bond is polar, so the molecules attract each other by dipole–dipole forces as well as London forces. A halogen atom also adds many electrons, which makes the London forces stronger. Boiling points rise from fluoro to iodo compounds and with chain length. Halogenoalkanes do not form hydrogen bonds with water, so they are almost insoluble in water but dissolve in organic solvents.

9.1Preparation of halogenoarenes and halogenoalkanesOften examined

Benzene does not react with chlorine or bromine on its own, because its delocalised π electrons are very stable. A halogen carrier (a Lewis acid catalyst) such as , or iron filings is needed. The reaction is electrophilic substitution: one hydrogen atom of the ring is replaced by a halogen atom and the ring stays aromatic.

general

benzene gives bromobenzene

benzene gives chlorobenzene

benzene
bromobenzene
chlorobenzene

Conditions: room temperature, dry reagents, in the dark. Iron filings work because iron reacts with bromine to form the real catalyst: . is also a Lewis acid and can act as a halogen carrier.

Mechanism: bromination of benzene
  1. Forming the electrophile. accepts a lone pair from one Br atom of . This polarises and breaks the Br–Br bond, giving a bromonium ion , the electrophile.
  2. Attack on the ring (slow). A pair of π electrons of the ring attacks and forms a C–Br bond. The ring loses its aromatic stability and becomes a positively charged arenium ion (σ-complex).
  3. Loss of a proton (fast). removes from the carbon that carries Br. The electron pair returns to the ring, the aromatic ring is restored and the catalyst is regenerated.

Preparation of halogenoalkanes (background)

Halogenoalkanes themselves are made by reactions from the Grade 11 units on alkanes, alkenes and alcohols. They are worth knowing for retrosynthesis (section 9.6).

Starting materialReagent and conditionsExample
Alkane or in UV light (free-radical substitution, gives a mixture)
Alkenehydrogen halide at room temperature (electrophilic addition)
Alcoholphosphorus pentachloride
Alcoholthionyl chloride (by-products are gases)
Alcohol and concentrated (makes )

9.2Reactivity of halogenoalkanes and halogenoarenesOften examined

The strength and polarity of the bond decide how a halogen compound reacts. Halogens are more electronegative than carbon, so carbon carries a partial positive charge () and the halogen a partial negative charge ().

In chloroethane the carbon is attacked by a nucleophile (an electron-pair donor, ). The bond breaks and chlorine leaves as a chloride ion. This is nucleophilic substitution:

In chlorobenzene one lone pair on the chlorine atom overlaps with the π electrons of the ring and is delocalised over the ring. The bond gains partial double-bond character, so it is shorter and stronger than in chloroethane and difficult to break. The chlorine atom therefore cannot be replaced by a nucleophile under normal conditions. The resonance structures show this:

Resonance structures of chlorobenzene. In II to IV the C–Cl bond is double and a negative charge sits at C2, C4 or C6 (ortho and para).

In structures II to IV the C–Cl bond is drawn as a double bond, and negative charge appears at the ortho (2, 6) and para (4) carbons. The real molecule is a hybrid of I to IV.

Why chlorobenzene resists nucleophilic substitution
  • Partial double bond. The bond is shorter (, against in chloroethane) and stronger.
  • ** carbon.** An carbon holds its electrons more tightly than an carbon, so the bond is less polar and the carbon less .
  • Electron-rich ring. The π cloud repels an approaching nucleophile, and the ring blocks attack from the back of the carbon (no ).
  • Unstable cation. A phenyl cation would be very unstable, so the route is not possible either.
Comparing a halogenoalkane with a halogenoarene
PropertyChloroethane Chlorobenzene
Carbon of the bond
bondsingle, partial double,
Warm aqueous ethanol forms (substitution)no reaction (needs about and high pressure)
Warm in aqueous ethanolwhite precipitate of AgCl forms slowlyno precipitate
Typical reactionsnucleophilic substitution and eliminationelectrophilic substitution of the ring
Electrophilic substitution of chlorobenzene

Chlorobenzene still has an aromatic ring, so it reacts with electrophiles. The chlorine atom directs the incoming group to the ortho (2-) and para (4-) positions, where its lone pair raises the electron density (structures II to IV). For example, nitration gives a mixture of 2-nitrochlorobenzene and 4-nitrochlorobenzene:

the two products are the ortho and para isomers

2-nitrochlorobenzene (ortho)
4-nitrochlorobenzene (para)

9.3Polarity of the C–X bond and the inductive effect

Halogens are more electronegative than carbon (Pauling values: F 4.0, Cl 3.0, Br 2.8, I 2.5, C 2.5). The halogen pulls the bonding pair towards itself, so it gains a partial negative charge and the carbon a partial positive charge. The halogen atoms induce a dipole in the carbon–halogen bond:

\ce{C^{\delta+}-X^{\delta-}}
Inductive effect
The permanent shift of σ-bond electrons towards the more electronegative atom, which makes the bond polar. Groups that pull electrons (halogens, \ce{-NO2}) show a -I effect; groups that push electrons (alkyl groups such as \ce{-CH3}) show a +I effect.

The polar \ce{C-X} bond explains the two types of reactions of halogenoalkanes:

  1. Nucleophilic substitution (SN reactions): a nucleophile attacks the \delta+ carbon and replaces X.
  2. Elimination: a base removes \ce{H} and \ce{X} from neighbouring carbons, forming an alkene.

9.3.1Nucleophilic substitution: substrate, nucleophile and leaving groupOften examined

The reaction in which the halogen atom of an alkyl halide is replaced by a stronger nucleophile is a nucleophilic substitution (SN) reaction. The general equation is:

\ce{:Nu- + R-X -> R-Nu + :X-}

\ce{Nu-}: attacking nucleophile; \ce{R-X}: substrate; \ce{X-}: leaving group

Substrate
The alkyl halide molecule that the nucleophile attacks.
Nucleophile
A species with a lone pair of electrons that it donates to the electrophilic (\delta+) carbon of the alkyl halide to form a new bond. It may be negatively charged (\ce{OH-}, \ce{CN-}) or neutral (\ce{H2O}, \ce{NH3}). The word means 'nucleus-loving'.
Leaving group
The group that departs with the bonding pair of electrons. In an alkyl halide it is the halide ion \ce{X-}.
Examples of nucleophiles
NucleophileNameNucleophileName
\ce{HO-}hydroxide ion\ce{NH2-}amide ion
\ce{C2H5O-}ethoxide ion\ce{Cl-}chloride ion
\ce{HS-}hydrogen sulphide ion\ce{Br-}bromide ion
\ce{SCN-}thiocyanate ion\ce{NH3}ammonia (neutral)
\ce{H2O}water (neutral)\ce{CN-}cyanide ion

Leaving groups. A good leaving group is a weak base that is stable on its own: \ce{I-}, \ce{Br-}, \ce{Cl-} and \ce{HSO4-}. Strong bases such as \ce{OH-}, \ce{RO-} and \ce{NH2-} are poor leaving groups. The incoming nucleophile must be stronger than the departing one. The iodide ion is both a good nucleophile and a good leaving group.

Every nucleophilic substitution involves two events: (1) breaking of the σ bond between carbon and halogen, and (2) formation of a new σ bond between carbon and the attacking nucleophile. In primary (and many secondary) alkyl halides both events happen together in one step: this is the **\mathrm{S_N2} mechanism. In bulky tertiary alkyl halides the C–X bond breaks first and the nucleophile bonds afterwards, in two steps: this is the \mathrm{S_N1}** mechanism.

Products of nucleophilic substitution

The book's summary diagram of reactions of \ce{R-X}, as a table
Nucleophile (reagent)ProductClass of product
\ce{OH-} (aqueous NaOH or KOH)\ce{R-OH}alcohol
\ce{R'O-} (sodium alkoxide)\ce{R-O-R'}ether
\ce{CN-} (KCN in ethanol)\ce{R-C#N}nitrile
\ce{NH3} (in ethanol)\ce{R-NH3+X-}, then \ce{R-NH2}ammonium salt, then amine
\ce{HS-}\ce{R-SH}thiol
\ce{I-}\ce{R-I}alkyl iodide
\ce{R'COO-} (carboxylate ion)\ce{R'COO-R}ester
\ce{R'C#C-} (alkynide ion)\ce{R-C#C-R'}alkyne

9.3.1Carbocations and their stabilityOften examined

Carbocation
A carbon atom that is attached to three atoms or groups of atoms and carries a unit positive charge. The positive carbon has only six electrons in its outer shell. The book also uses the older name carbonium ion.

The positive carbon is sp^2 hybridised. Its three bonds lie in one plane at 120^\circ (trigonal planar), and the empty 2p orbital lies above and below that plane. The empty orbital is what a nucleophile attacks, from either side.

Carbocations are classified like halogenoalkanes, by the number of alkyl groups on the positive carbon: methyl \ce{CH3+}, primary \ce{RCH2+}, secondary \ce{R2CH+}, tertiary \ce{R3C+}.

The four kinds of carbocation. Each positive carbon is trigonal planar; more alkyl groups mean more stability.
3^\circ \;>\; 2^\circ \;>\; 1^\circ \;>\; \text{methyl}
stability

most stable on the left, least stable on the right (book Fig. 9.1)

Alkyl groups release electrons towards the positive carbon (+I effect). Three alkyl groups spread the charge most; hydrogen atoms cannot.

Why alkyl groups stabilise a carbocation

  1. **Inductive effect (+I).** An alkyl group is electron-releasing. It pushes σ-bond electron density towards the positive carbon, which partly neutralises the charge. Spreading (dispersing) a charge over more atoms lowers the energy and makes the ion more stable. A tertiary cation has three alkyl groups pushing; a methyl cation has none.
  2. Hyperconjugation. A C–H σ bond on a carbon next to \ce{C+} can overlap with the empty 2p orbital and share its electron pair a little. The more such C–H bonds, the greater the stabilisation: \ce{(CH3)3C+} has 9, \ce{(CH3)2CH+} has 6, \ce{CH3CH2+} has 3 and \ce{CH3+} has none.

9.3.1SN1 mechanismOften examined

\mathrm{S_N1}
Substitution, nucleophilic, unimolecular. A two-step mechanism in which the substrate R–X first ionises into a carbocation (\ce{R+}) and \ce{X-}; the carbocation is then attacked by the nucleophile. Only one species, the substrate, takes part in the slow (rate-determining) step.
Mechanism: hydrolysis of 2-bromo-2-methylpropane
  1. Step 1: ionisation (slow, rate-determining). The \ce{C-Br} bond breaks heterolytically: the bonding pair moves completely onto bromine. A planar tertiary carbocation and a bromide ion form. This step needs the most energy, so it is slow and it controls the rate.
    \ce{(CH3)3C-Br <=>[slow] (CH3)3C+ + Br-}
  2. Step 2: attack by the nucleophile (fast). A lone pair of the nucleophile is donated to the empty 2p orbital of the carbocation, forming the new C–O bond. Oppositely charged ions attract strongly, so this step is fast.
    \ce{(CH3)3C+ + OH- ->[fast] (CH3)3C-OH}
  3. With water as the nucleophile an oxonium ion forms first; it then loses a proton to another water molecule.
    \ce{(CH3)3C+ + H2O -> (CH3)3C-OH2+ ->[-H+] (CH3)3C-OH}
2-bromo-2-methylpropane
carbocation (planar)
oxonium ion
2-methylpropan-2-ol

Rate equation

Only the substrate takes part in the slow step, so the rate depends only on its concentration. The nucleophile reacts after the slow step, so changing [\ce{OH-}] does not change the rate.

\text{rate}=k[\ce{R-X}]\qquad\text{for example}\qquad\text{rate}=k[\ce{(CH3)3CBr}]

The reaction is first order overall: first order in R–X and zero order in the nucleophile. 'Unimolecular' means one molecule takes part in the rate-determining step. k is the rate constant (unit \mathrm{s^{-1}}).

Energy profiles. \mathrm{S_N1} has two humps with a carbocation intermediate between them; the first hump (ionisation) is the higher one. \mathrm{S_N2} has a single hump, the transition state.

Stereochemistry: racemisation

The flat carbocation can be attacked from either face with equal chance.

If the carbon carrying the halogen is a chiral centre, \mathrm{S_N1} gives a 50 : 50 mixture of the two enantiomers (a racemic mixture), which is optically inactive.

Conditions that favour \mathrm{S_N1}
  • a tertiary (highly branched) substrate: it gives a stable carbocation and is too crowded for attack from the back
  • a weak or neutral nucleophile such as \ce{H2O} or an alcohol
  • a polar protic solvent such as water, which stabilises the ions formed in step 1
  • a good leaving group (\ce{I-} > \ce{Br-} > \ce{Cl-})

SN2 mechanismOften examined

\mathrm{S_N2}
Substitution, nucleophilic, bimolecular. A one-step (concerted) mechanism: the nucleophile attacks the carbon from the side opposite the halogen while the C–X bond breaks. Two species take part in the single step.
\mathrm{S_N2}: attack from the back, a five-coordinate transition state, and inversion of the three groups like an umbrella turned inside out.
Mechanism: bromoethane with hydroxide ion
  1. Backside attack. \ce{OH-} approaches the \delta+ carbon from the side exactly opposite (180^\circ) to the Br atom, the side not blocked by the large Br atom and its electrons.
  2. Transition state. As the O–C bond starts to form, the C–Br bond starts to break. For an instant the carbon is partly bonded to five groups: O and Br on a straight line, the other three groups in a flat plane. O and Br both carry partial negative charges. This is an energy maximum (transition state, marked \ddagger), not an intermediate; it cannot be isolated.
    \ce{HO- + CH3CH2Br -> [HO^{\delta-}\cdots C\cdots Br^{\delta-}]^{\ddagger} -> CH3CH2OH + Br-}
  3. Bond breaking complete. Br leaves as \ce{Br-} with the bonding pair. The three groups on the carbon flip over, so the product has an inverted configuration (Walden inversion).
bromoethane
ethanol

Rate equation

\text{rate}=k[\ce{R-X}][\ce{Nu-}]\qquad\text{for example}\qquad\text{rate}=k[\ce{CH3CH2Br}][\ce{OH-}]

Both species are in the single step, so doubling either concentration doubles the rate. The reaction is first order in each reactant and second order overall; k has the unit \mathrm{dm^3\,mol^{-1}\,s^{-1}}.

Conditions that favour \mathrm{S_N2}
  • a methyl or primary substrate: the back of the carbon is not crowded
  • a strong, negatively charged nucleophile (\ce{OH-}, \ce{CN-}, \ce{RO-}) at good concentration
  • a polar aprotic solvent (for example propanone), which does not surround the nucleophile with hydrogen bonds
  • a good leaving group
\mathrm{S_N2\ rate}:\quad \ce{CH3X} > 1^\circ > 2^\circ > 3^\circ

Effect of alkyl groups: which mechanismOften examined

The structure of the halogenoalkane decides the mechanism. Alkyl groups on the carbon carrying X have two effects that point in opposite directions.

FactorPrimary (1°)Tertiary (3°)
Crowding at the back of the carbon (steric hindrance)one alkyl group; the back is open, so \mathrm{S_N2} is easythree bulky alkyl groups block the back, so \mathrm{S_N2} is almost impossible
Stability of the carbocationa 1^\circ cation is very unstable (only one +I group), so \mathrm{S_N1} is too slowa 3^\circ cation is stabilised by three +I groups and hyperconjugation, so \mathrm{S_N1} is fast
Mechanism followed\mathrm{S_N2}\mathrm{S_N1}

Secondary halogenoalkanes are in between. Their carbocation is fairly stable and the back of the carbon is partly crowded, so they react by a mixture of both mechanisms. A strong nucleophile in a polar aprotic solvent pushes them towards \mathrm{S_N2}; a weak nucleophile in water pushes them towards \mathrm{S_N1}.

\mathrm{S_N1\ rate}:\ 3^\circ>2^\circ>1^\circ>\ce{CH3X}\qquad\qquad \mathrm{S_N2\ rate}:\ \ce{CH3X}>1^\circ>2^\circ>3^\circ
\mathrm{S_N1} and \mathrm{S_N2} compared
Feature\mathrm{S_N1}\mathrm{S_N2}
Meaningsubstitution, nucleophilic, unimolecularsubstitution, nucleophilic, bimolecular
Stepstwoone (concerted)
Species in the slow step\ce{R-X} only\ce{R-X} and \ce{Nu-}
Rate equation\text{rate}=k[\ce{RX}]\text{rate}=k[\ce{RX}][\ce{Nu-}]
Orderfirstsecond
Intermediatecarbocationnone (only a transition state)
Stereochemistryracemisationinversion of configuration
Favoured bytertiary R–X, weak nucleophile, polar protic solventmethyl or primary R–X, strong nucleophile, aprotic solvent
Example\ce{(CH3)3CBr + H2O}\ce{CH3CH2Br + OH-}

Elimination reactionsOften examined

A halogenoalkane can also lose a hydrogen halide (\ce{HX}) to form an alkene. Here the \ce{OH-} ion acts as a base: it removes a proton (\ce{H+}) from the carbon next to the C–X carbon instead of attacking the carbon itself. This is elimination (dehydrohalogenation).

α-carbon
The carbon atom bonded to the halogen.
β-carbon
A carbon atom next to the α-carbon; the hydrogen removed in elimination comes from here.
β-elimination
Loss of X from the α-carbon and H from the β-carbon, which forms a C=C double bond between them.
\ce{CH3CH2Br + KOH ->[ethanol][heat] CH2=CH2 + KBr + H2O}

bromoethane gives ethene

\ce{CH3CHBrCH3 + KOH ->[ethanol][heat] CH3CH=CH2 + KBr + H2O}

2-bromopropane gives propene

E2 mechanism (one step)
  1. The base (\ce{OH-} or ethoxide \ce{C2H5O-}) uses a lone pair to remove a proton from the β-carbon.
  2. At the same moment the electron pair of that C–H bond moves between the two carbons and forms the π bond.
  3. The C–Br bond breaks and \ce{Br-} leaves with the bonding pair. All three changes happen in one step, so \text{rate}=k[\ce{R-X}][\text{base}] (second order).
    \ce{HO- + H-CH2-CH2-Br -> H2O + CH2=CH2 + Br-}

Tertiary halogenoalkanes can also eliminate by an E1 route: the same slow ionisation as \mathrm{S_N1}, then loss of \ce{H+} from a β-carbon of the carbocation; \text{rate}=k[\ce{R-X}].

Which alkene forms: Saytzeff (Zaitsev) rule

If the halogen carbon has two different β-carbons, two alkenes can form. The major product is the more substituted alkene (fewer hydrogen atoms on the C=C carbons), because it is more stable.

\ce{CH3CHBrCH2CH3 ->[KOH,\ ethanol][heat] CH3CH=CHCH3 + CH2=CHCH2CH3}

but-2-ene is the major product (about 80%), but-1-ene the minor one

2-bromobutane
but-2-ene (major)
but-1-ene (minor)
Substitution or elimination
ConditionFavours substitutionFavours elimination
Solventwater (aqueous \ce{OH-})ethanol (alcoholic \ce{OH-})
Temperaturewarm (lower)hot (higher)
Basediluteconcentrated
Structure of R–Xprimarytertiary

Predicting products: KCN, ammonia and hydroxideOften examined

Many questions give a halogenoalkane and a reagent and ask for the product. Decide first whether the reagent acts as a nucleophile or a base, then use the conditions and the structure of the halogenoalkane.

Reagent and conditionsRoleProduct from chloroethane \ce{CH3CH2Cl}Type of reaction
\ce{NaOH} or \ce{KOH} (aqueous), warmnucleophileethanol \ce{CH3CH2OH}nucleophilic substitution (hydrolysis)
\ce{KOH} in ethanol, hotbaseethene \ce{CH2=CH2}elimination
\ce{KCN} in ethanol, heat under refluxnucleophile \ce{CN-}propanenitrile \ce{CH3CH2CN}nucleophilic substitution
excess \ce{NH3} in ethanol, heated in a sealed tubenucleophileethylamine \ce{CH3CH2NH2}nucleophilic substitution
\ce{AgNO3} in aqueous ethanol, warmwater is the nucleophile; \ce{Ag+} takes the \ce{Cl-}ethanol and a white precipitate of AgClhydrolysis (test for the halogen)
With KCN: nitriles
\ce{CH3CH2Cl + KCN ->[ethanol][reflux] CH3CH2CN + KCl}

The cyanide ion attacks the \delta+ carbon through its carbon atom, so a new C–C bond forms and the chain grows by one carbon. Chloroethane (2 C) gives propanenitrile (3 C), not ethanenitrile. Ethanol is used as the solvent because in water some \ce{OH-} would form and give the alcohol as well.

Nitriles are useful because the \ce{-C#N} group can be changed further: acid hydrolysis gives a carboxylic acid and reduction gives an amine.

\ce{CH3CH2CN + 2H2O + H+ ->[heat] CH3CH2COOH + NH4+}
\ce{CH3CH2CN + 4[H] ->[LiAlH4] CH3CH2CH2NH2}
chloroethane
propanenitrile
propanoic acid
With ammonia: amines
\ce{CH3CH2Br + NH3 ->[ethanol][heat,\ sealed\ tube] CH3CH2NH3+Br-}
\ce{CH3CH2NH3+Br- + NH3 <=> CH3CH2NH2 + NH4+Br-}

The lone pair on nitrogen attacks the carbon, giving an ethylammonium salt. A second ammonia molecule removes a proton and frees the amine. Overall: \ce{CH3CH2Br + 2NH3 -> CH3CH2NH2 + NH4Br}. Ammonia is used in excess, because the amine formed also has a lone pair and would attack more halogenoalkane to give secondary and tertiary amines and finally a quaternary ammonium salt. The sealed tube keeps the volatile ammonia in the hot solution.

ethylamine
diethylamine (from further substitution)
With hydroxide: aqueous or alcoholic
\ce{CH3CH2Cl + NaOH ->[H2O][warm] CH3CH2OH + NaCl}

substitution, the main reaction at lower temperature in water

\ce{CH3CH2Cl + KOH ->[ethanol][heat] CH2=CH2 + KCl + H2O}

elimination, the main reaction in hot ethanol

Reactivity and C–X bond strength: the silver nitrate testOften examined

Two properties of the C–X bond could control how fast it breaks: its polarity (largest for C–F) and its strength (also largest for C–F). Experiments show that reactivity increases from fluoro to iodo compounds, so bond strength is the deciding factor: the weaker the bond, the faster it breaks.

Approximate average values. Longer bonds are weaker.
BondBond enthalpy / \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}Bond length / \mathrm{pm}Reactivity
C–F485139lowest (almost unreactive)
C–Cl339178low
C–Br285193higher
C–I218214highest
\ce{R-I} > \ce{R-Br} > \ce{R-Cl} > \ce{R-F}
reactivity
Reaction with aqueous silver nitrate

A few drops of the halogenoalkane are added to silver nitrate solution in ethanol and water (ethanol lets the two liquids mix), and the tube is warmed in a water bath. Water slowly hydrolyses the C–X bond. Each halide ion released meets an \ce{Ag+} ion and forms a silver halide precipitate, so the time taken for the precipitate to appear shows how fast the C–X bond breaks.

\ce{R-X + H2O -> R-OH + H+ + X-}
\ce{Ag+(aq) + X-(aq) -> AgX(s)}

The book writes the overall change as \ce{R-X + AgNO3 -> R-NO3 + AgX}, where X is Cl, Br or I. Alkyl fluorides do not react, because the C–F bond is too strong and no fluoride ion is released.

HalogenoalkanePrecipitateSpeedWith \ce{NH4OH} (aqueous ammonia)
R–ClAgCl, whiteslowestsoluble
R–BrAgBr, creamfasterpartially soluble (dissolves in concentrated ammonia)
R–IAgI, yellowfastestinsoluble
R–Fnoneno reactionnot applicable

9.6Alkyl halides and retrosynthesisOften examined

Alkyl halides are good starting materials for many organic compounds, because the halogen can be replaced by many different groups. Retrosynthesis means working backwards from the product (the target) to find the starting materials. The open arrow \Longrightarrow means 'can be made from'.

In \ce{R-X + Nu- -> R-Nu + X-} the new bond is C–Nu. So we mentally disconnect the target at that bond: the carbon part R came from the halogenoalkane, and the group Nu came from the nucleophile.

\ce{R-Nu}\;\Longrightarrow\;\ce{R+ + Nu-}\qquad\text{so the starting materials are}\qquad\ce{R-X}\ \text{and}\ \ce{Nu-}
Method
  1. Find the functional group in the target (for example \ce{-OH}, \ce{-CN}, \ce{-NH2}) and the carbon it is attached to.
  2. Disconnect the bond between that carbon and the functional group.
  3. Put a halogen (usually Br or Cl) on the same carbon: this is the halogenoalkane. The group becomes the nucleophile (\ce{OH-}, \ce{CN-}, \ce{NH3}).
  4. Check the number of carbon atoms (the nitrile route adds one carbon) and write the forward equation with reagent and conditions.
Ethanol (book example)
Deduce the starting material for making ethanol by nucleophilic substitution.
  1. The target is ethanol, \ce{CH3CH2OH}. Disconnect the C–O bond.
    \ce{CH3-CH2-OH}\;\Longrightarrow\;\ce{CH3-CH2+ + OH-}
  2. The ethyl group comes from a haloethane, the \ce{OH} from hydroxide ions. Use bromoethane.
  3. Forward reaction:
    \ce{CH3CH2Br + OH- ->[aqueous][warm] CH3CH2OH + Br-}
\text{starting material: } \ce{CH3CH2Br}\ \text{(bromoethane)}
Propan-2-ol (2026 Set B)
Deduce the halogenoalkane that gives \ce{CH3CH(OH)CH3}.
  1. The OH group is on the middle carbon (C2), so disconnect the C2–O bond.
    \ce{CH3CH(OH)CH3}\;\Longrightarrow\;\ce{CH3CH+CH3 + OH-}
  2. Put Br on the same carbon: 2-bromopropane.
  3. Forward reaction:
    \ce{CH3CHBrCH3 + NaOH ->[aqueous][warm] CH3CH(OH)CH3 + NaBr}
\ce{CH3CHBrCH3}\ \text{(2-bromopropane)}
Butanenitrile (adding one carbon)
Deduce the halogenoalkane needed to make butanenitrile \ce{CH3CH2CH2CN}.
  1. The target has 4 carbons, one of which is in the \ce{-C#N} group. Disconnect the C–CN bond.
    \ce{CH3CH2CH2-CN}\;\Longrightarrow\;\ce{CH3CH2CH2+ + CN-}
  2. The halogenoalkane has only 3 carbons: 1-bromopropane.
  3. Forward reaction:
    \ce{CH3CH2CH2Br + KCN ->[ethanol][reflux] CH3CH2CH2CN + KBr}
\ce{CH3CH2CH2Br}\ \text{(1-bromopropane)}
Propanoic acid in two steps
Show how propanoic acid \ce{CH3CH2COOH} can be made from a halogenoalkane.
  1. A carboxylic acid can be made by hydrolysing a nitrile with the same number of carbons.
    \ce{CH3CH2COOH}\;\Longrightarrow\;\ce{CH3CH2CN}
  2. The nitrile comes from a halogenoalkane with one carbon fewer.
    \ce{CH3CH2CN}\;\Longrightarrow\;\ce{CH3CH2Cl + CN-}
  3. Forward route:
    \ce{CH3CH2Cl ->[KCN,\ ethanol][reflux] CH3CH2CN ->[H3O+][heat] CH3CH2COOH}
\ce{CH3CH2Cl}\ \text{(chloroethane)}

Uses and environmental effects

UseExamples
Solvents (degreasing, dry cleaning, extraction)dichloromethane \ce{CH2Cl2}, trichloromethane \ce{CHCl3}; tetrachloromethane \ce{CCl4} in the past
Anaestheticshalothane \ce{CF3CHBrCl}; chloroform \ce{CHCl3} in the past
Refrigerants and aerosol propellantsCFCs such as \ce{CCl2F2} (now banned), replaced by HFCs such as \ce{CF3CH2F}
Fire extinguishershalons such as \ce{CF3Br} (now restricted)
Polymerschloroethene \ce{CH2=CHCl} for PVC; tetrafluoroethene \ce{CF2=CF2} for PTFE (Teflon)
PesticidesDDT (now banned in most countries)
Organic synthesisstarting materials for alcohols, nitriles, amines, ethers and Grignard reagents
CFCs and the ozone layer

CFCs are unreactive in the lower atmosphere, because their C–F and C–Cl bonds are strong, so they slowly rise into the stratosphere. There, ultraviolet light breaks the weaker C–Cl bond and releases chlorine atoms (free radicals), which destroy ozone in a chain reaction:

\ce{CCl2F2 ->[UV] CClF2^{\bullet} + Cl^{\bullet}}
\ce{Cl^{\bullet} + O3 -> ClO^{\bullet} + O2}
\ce{ClO^{\bullet} + O -> Cl^{\bullet} + O2}

The chlorine atom is regenerated in the last step, so one chlorine atom can destroy many thousands of ozone molecules; the net change is \ce{O3 + O -> 2O2}. A thinner ozone layer lets more harmful ultraviolet radiation reach the Earth, which increases skin cancer and eye cataracts and damages crops and plankton.

  • Ozone depletion: CFCs, halons and \ce{CCl4}.
  • Global warming: CFCs and HFCs are strong greenhouse gases.
  • Persistence and bioaccumulation: DDT and other organochlorine pesticides build up in food chains and harm birds and fish.
  • Toxicity: many chlorinated solvents damage the liver and the nervous system.

Formula sheet

General nucleophilic substitution
\ce{Nu- + R-X -> R-Nu + X-}
\ce{Nu-}: nucleophile; \ce{R-X}: halogenoalkane (substrate); \ce{X-}: leaving group (halide ion)
Rate equation for \mathrm{S_N1}
\text{rate}=k[\ce{R-X}]
k: rate constant; first order overall; the nucleophile does not appear
Unit: k in \mathrm{s^{-1}}
Rate equation for \mathrm{S_N2}
\text{rate}=k[\ce{R-X}][\ce{Nu-}]
k: rate constant; second order overall
Unit: k in \mathrm{dm^3\,mol^{-1}\,s^{-1}}
Carbocation stability
3^\circ>2^\circ>1^\circ>\ce{CH3+}
more alkyl groups on \ce{C+} give more +I donation and hyperconjugation
Halogenation of benzene
\ce{C6H6 + X2 ->[FeX3] C6H5X + HX}
X: Cl or Br; \ce{FeX3}: halogen carrier (Lewis acid)
Hydrolysis (aqueous hydroxide)
\ce{R-X + OH- ->[aqueous][warm] R-OH + X-}
substitution gives an alcohol
Elimination (alcoholic hydroxide)
\ce{RCH2CH2X + OH- ->[ethanol][heat] RCH=CH2 + H2O + X-}
dehydrohalogenation gives an alkene
Nitrile formation
\ce{R-X + CN- ->[ethanol][reflux] R-CN + X-}
adds one carbon atom to the chain
Amine formation
\ce{R-X + 2NH3 ->[ethanol][sealed\ tube] R-NH2 + NH4X}
ammonia in excess
Silver nitrate test
\ce{Ag+(aq) + X-(aq) -> AgX(s)}
AgCl white, AgBr cream, AgI yellow; rate R–I > R–Br > R–Cl
Ozone destruction by chlorine atoms
\ce{Cl^{\bullet} + O3 -> ClO^{\bullet} + O2}
followed by \ce{ClO^{\bullet} + O -> Cl^{\bullet} + O2}, which regenerates the chlorine atom

Key terms

Halogenoalkane (alkyl halide)
A compound in which a hydrogen atom of an alkane is replaced by a halogen atom; general formula \ce{R-X}.
Halogenoarene (aryl halide)
A compound with a halogen atom bonded directly to a benzene ring; general formula \ce{Ar-X}.
Primary, secondary, tertiary halogenoalkane
The carbon carrying the halogen is bonded to one, two or three other carbon atoms.
Halogen carrier
A Lewis acid such as \ce{FeCl3}, \ce{FeBr3} or \ce{AlCl3} that polarises a halogen molecule to give the electrophile \ce{X+}.
Arenium ion
The positively charged intermediate formed when an electrophile bonds to a benzene ring (σ-complex).
Inductive effect
The shift of σ-bond electrons towards the more electronegative atom; -I groups pull electrons, +I groups (alkyl groups) push them.
Nucleophile
A species with a lone pair of electrons that it donates to an electron-poor carbon to form a new bond.
Electrophile
A species that accepts a pair of electrons; it is attracted to electron-rich sites.
Substrate
The molecule (here the halogenoalkane) that is attacked by the reagent.
Leaving group
The atom or group that departs with the bonding pair of electrons, such as \ce{Cl-}, \ce{Br-} or \ce{I-}.
Nucleophilic substitution
A reaction in which a nucleophile replaces an atom or group (here the halogen) in a molecule.
\mathrm{S_N1}
Unimolecular nucleophilic substitution: two steps, via a carbocation; \text{rate}=k[\ce{R-X}].
\mathrm{S_N2}
Bimolecular nucleophilic substitution: one step, backside attack through a transition state; \text{rate}=k[\ce{R-X}][\ce{Nu-}].
Rate-determining step
The slowest step of a mechanism; it controls the overall rate.
Carbocation (carbonium ion)
A species with a positively charged carbon that is bonded to three atoms or groups.
Hyperconjugation
Stabilisation of a carbocation by overlap of neighbouring C–H σ bonds with its empty p orbital.
Steric hindrance
Slowing of a reaction because bulky groups block the approach of the attacking species.
Transition state
The highest-energy arrangement of atoms during a reaction step; it cannot be isolated.
Intermediate
A species formed in one step and used up in a later step, such as the carbocation in \mathrm{S_N1}.
Walden inversion
The umbrella-like inversion of configuration at a carbon atom during an \mathrm{S_N2} reaction.
Racemic mixture
An equal mixture of two enantiomers; it is optically inactive. \mathrm{S_N1} at a chiral carbon gives one.
Elimination (dehydrohalogenation)
Removal of H and X from neighbouring carbon atoms by a base, forming an alkene.
Saytzeff (Zaitsev) rule
In elimination the more substituted alkene is the major product.
Retrosynthesis
Working backwards from a target molecule to find suitable starting materials; shown with the open arrow \Longrightarrow.
Disconnection
An imaginary breaking of a bond in the target molecule during retrosynthesis.
CFC
Chlorofluorocarbon, such as \ce{CCl2F2}; releases chlorine atoms in the stratosphere that destroy ozone.

Multiple choice questionsp. 179

Printed page 181. The rest of the exercise (printed page 182) is still to be added, so only MCQs i to viii are given here.

i1 mark
Which catalyst is commonly used in the halogenation of benzene with \ce{Cl2} or \ce{Br2}?
  1. A\ce{H2SO4}
  2. B\ce{FeCl3}Answer
  3. C\ce{AlCl3}
  4. D\ce{NaOH}
Why

Halogenation of benzene needs a Lewis acid halogen carrier. The book uses \ce{FeX3} (or iron filings): \ce{FeCl3} polarises \ce{Cl2} and produces the electrophile \ce{Cl+}. \ce{H2SO4} is the catalyst for nitration, and \ce{NaOH} is not a catalyst here.

\ce{AlCl3} is also a Lewis acid and can carry a halogen, but it is the usual catalyst for Friedel–Crafts reactions; the catalyst named for halogenation in this unit is \ce{FeCl3}.

Note. Options B and C are both Lewis acids that can catalyse halogenation. Following the book (section 9.1), the expected answer is B.

ii1 mark
In the reaction of benzene with \ce{Cl2} in the presence of a catalyst, the product is:
  1. AChloromethane
  2. BChlorobenzeneAnswer
  3. CDichloromethane
  4. DBenzyl chloride
Why

One hydrogen of the ring is replaced by chlorine: \ce{C6H6 + Cl2 ->[FeCl3] C6H5Cl + HCl}. Chloromethane and dichloromethane come from methane, and benzyl chloride \ce{C6H5CH2Cl} comes from chlorinating the side chain of methylbenzene in UV light.

iii1 mark
What is the major product of the reaction between benzene and \ce{Br2} with \ce{FeBr3} as a catalyst?
  1. ABenzene bromide
  2. BBromobenzeneAnswer
  3. CDibromobenzene
  4. DBromomethane
Why

Electrophilic substitution puts one Br on the ring: \ce{C6H6 + Br2 ->[FeBr3] C6H5Br + HBr}. 'Benzene bromide' is not a correct name, dibromobenzene needs excess bromine, and bromomethane is made from methane.

iv1 mark
Which mechanism do primary halogenoalkanes typically follow in nucleophilic substitution reactions?
  1. A\mathrm{S_N1}
  2. B\mathrm{S_N2}Answer
  3. C\mathrm{S_N1} and \mathrm{S_N2} both
  4. DNone of these
Why

A primary halogenoalkane has only one alkyl group on the C–X carbon, so the back of that carbon is open for attack (\mathrm{S_N2}). A primary carbocation is very unstable, so the \mathrm{S_N1} route is too slow. A mixture of both mechanisms is typical of secondary halogenoalkanes.

v1 mark
What type of bond is broken in the nucleophilic substitution reaction of a halogenoalkane?
  1. AC–H
  2. BC–O
  3. CC–X (where X is a halogen)Answer
  4. DC–C
Why

The nucleophile replaces the halogen, so the carbon–halogen bond breaks and X leaves as \ce{X-} with the bonding pair: \ce{R-X + Nu- -> R-Nu + X-}. A C–H bond is broken in elimination, not in substitution.

vi1 mark
Which factor does NOT significantly affect the rate of \mathrm{S_N1} reactions?
  1. AStability of the carbocation
  2. BSolvent polarity
  3. CStrength of the nucleophileAnswer
  4. DLeaving group ability
Why

For \mathrm{S_N1}, \text{rate}=k[\ce{R-X}]. The nucleophile reacts only after the slow ionisation step, so its strength (and concentration) hardly changes the rate. Carbocation stability, a polar solvent and a good leaving group all make the slow ionisation step easier.

vii2026 Annual I, Old syllabus (Curriculum 2006), MCQ 12, old syllabus1 mark
Which halogenoalkane is more reactive in an \mathrm{S_N2} reaction?
  1. AChloromethaneAnswer
  2. BChlorobenzene
  3. CChloroethane
  4. DAll of these
Why

\mathrm{S_N2} needs attack from the back of the carbon. In chloromethane the carbon carries only small hydrogen atoms, so it is the least hindered and reacts fastest. Chloroethane is slower because of its methyl group, and chlorobenzene does not undergo \mathrm{S_N2} at all (partial double bond, ring blocks the back), so 'all of these' is wrong.

viii1 mark
The C–Cl bond in chlorobenzene is less reactive towards nucleophilic substitution because:
  1. AThe C–Cl bond is too strong
  2. BThe phenyl ring stabilizes the chlorine
  3. CResonance effect makes the bond partially doubleAnswer
  4. DSteric hindrance from the benzene ring
Why

A lone pair on chlorine is delocalised into the ring, which gives the C–Cl bond partial double-bond character. Option A describes the result (a stronger bond), but resonance is the cause, and this is the reason given in the book.

FBISE 2026 questions

Questions from the FBISE HSSC-II 2026 (1st Annual) papers that belong to this unit, answered the way an examiner expects.

2026 Annual I, Set B, MCQ 81 mark
When chloroethane reacts with aqueous \ce{OH-} at low temperature, main product is:
  1. AEthene
  2. BEthanolAnswer
  3. CBenzene
  4. DPhenol
Why

Aqueous hydroxide at a lower temperature acts as a nucleophile and substitutes the chlorine: \ce{CH3CH2Cl + OH- -> CH3CH2OH + Cl-}. Ethene forms by elimination with hot alcoholic KOH. Benzene and phenol cannot form from a two-carbon compound.

2026 Annual I, Set B, MCQ 111 mark
Nitriles are prepared from halogenoalkanes by reaction with KCN. This is an example of:
  1. ANucleophilic substitutionAnswer
  2. BElimination reaction
  3. CAddition reaction
  4. DPolymerization
Why

The cyanide ion is a nucleophile. It replaces the halogen: \ce{R-X + CN- -> R-CN + X-}. No double bond is formed (not elimination) and nothing adds across a multiple bond (not addition).

2026 Annual I, Set B, Q.2 (vii)3 marks
Given the alcohol product \ce{CH3CH(OH)CH3}, deduce the halogenoalkane starting material using retrosynthesis.
Solution

Retrosynthesis works backwards from the target. The target, propan-2-ol, is a secondary alcohol with the \ce{-OH} group on the middle carbon (C2). It can be made by nucleophilic substitution of a halogenoalkane by \ce{OH-}.

  1. Disconnect the C–O bond at C2 (the bond made in the last step).
    \ce{CH3CH(OH)CH3}\;\Longrightarrow\;\ce{CH3CH+CH3 + OH-}
  2. Identify the starting materials. The carbocation part comes from a halogenoalkane with the halogen on the same carbon, C2; the \ce{OH-} comes from aqueous NaOH or KOH. So the starting material is 2-bromopropane (2-chloropropane also works).
  3. Forward reaction. Warm with aqueous sodium hydroxide:
    \ce{CH3CHBrCH3 + NaOH ->[aqueous][warm] CH3CH(OH)CH3 + NaBr}
propan-2-ol (target)
2-bromopropane (starting material)
\ce{CH3CHBrCH3}\ \ \text{(2-bromopropane)}
2026 Annual I, Set B, Q.3 OR3+2+2 = 7 marks
Explain the \mathrm{S_N1} mechanism of nucleophilic substitution for tert-butyl bromide (\ce{(CH3)3CBr}) reacting with water. Your answer should:
  • Show the formation of the carbocation intermediate
  • Include the role of the inductive effect of alkyl groups in stabilizing the carbocation.

Write rate equation for given reaction.

Solution

Mechanism and the carbocation intermediate (3 marks)

tert-Butyl bromide (2-bromo-2-methylpropane) is a tertiary halogenoalkane, so it reacts by the \mathrm{S_N1} mechanism (substitution, nucleophilic, unimolecular). Water is the nucleophile, and the overall reaction is hydrolysis:

\ce{(CH3)3CBr + H2O -> (CH3)3COH + HBr}
  1. Step 1 (slow, rate-determining): formation of the carbocation. The polar \ce{C^{\delta+}-Br^{\delta-}} bond breaks heterolytically; both bonding electrons go to bromine. A tertiary carbocation and a bromide ion form.
    \ce{(CH3)3C-Br <=>[slow] (CH3)3C+ + Br-}
  2. Step 2 (fast): attack by water. A lone pair on the oxygen of water is donated to the empty 2p orbital of the planar carbocation, giving an oxonium ion.
    \ce{(CH3)3C+ + H2O ->[fast] (CH3)3C-OH2+}
  3. Step 3 (fast): loss of a proton. A second water molecule removes \ce{H+}, giving the alcohol, 2-methylpropan-2-ol.
    \ce{(CH3)3C-OH2+ + H2O -> (CH3)3C-OH + H3O+}
tert-butyl bromide
tert-butyl carbocation
oxonium ion
2-methylpropan-2-ol

The carbocation is sp^2 hybridised and planar, with an empty 2p orbital above and below the plane, so water can attack from either side.

Role of the inductive effect of alkyl groups (2 marks)

The three methyl groups push electron density towards the positive carbon (+I effect).

Methyl groups are electron-releasing (+I effect). The three methyl groups push σ-bond electron density towards the positive carbon. This partly neutralises and spreads out (disperses) the positive charge, and a dispersed charge is more stable. Hyperconjugation with the 9 neighbouring C–H bonds adds to this stabilisation.

Because the tertiary carbocation is the most stable kind (3^\circ > 2^\circ > 1^\circ > \text{methyl}), step 1 has a relatively low activation energy, so the ionisation can happen and the \mathrm{S_N1} route is followed. The three bulky methyl groups also block attack from the back of the carbon, which rules out \mathrm{S_N2}.

Rate equation (2 marks)

\text{rate}=k[\ce{(CH3)3CBr}]

Only tert-butyl bromide takes part in the slow step, so the rate depends only on its concentration. The reaction is first order; water does not appear in the rate equation because it reacts in a fast step after the slow one (and it is also the solvent). k is the rate constant, with unit \mathrm{s^{-1}}.

2026 Annual I, Set D, MCQ 91 mark
The product formed when chloroethane reacts with KCN is:
  1. AMethane
  2. BPropanenitrileAnswer
  3. CEthanol
  4. DMethanenitrile
Why

\ce{CH3CH2Cl + KCN -> CH3CH2CN + KCl}. The cyanide carbon joins the chain, so the two-carbon chloroethane gives a three-carbon nitrile, propanenitrile. Ethanol would need \ce{OH-} as the nucleophile.

2026 Annual I, Set D, Q.2 (viii) OR3 marks
Using retro-synthesis, deduce the starting halogenoalkane for the formation of 2-butanol.
Solution

The target is butan-2-ol (2-butanol), \ce{CH3CH(OH)CH2CH3}, a secondary alcohol with \ce{-OH} on C2. Alcohols are made from halogenoalkanes by substitution with \ce{OH-}, so we work backwards to the halogenoalkane.

  1. Disconnect the C2–O bond.
    \ce{CH3CH(OH)CH2CH3}\;\Longrightarrow\;\ce{CH3CH+CH2CH3 + OH-}
  2. Starting material. Put a halogen on the same carbon (C2): 2-bromobutane \ce{CH3CHBrCH2CH3} (or 2-chlorobutane). The nucleophile is \ce{OH-} from aqueous NaOH or KOH.
  3. Forward reaction. Warm with aqueous sodium hydroxide:
    \ce{CH3CHBrCH2CH3 + NaOH ->[aqueous][warm] CH3CH(OH)CH2CH3 + NaBr}
butan-2-ol (target)
2-bromobutane (starting material)
\ce{CH3CHBrCH2CH3}\ \ \text{(2-bromobutane)}
2026 Annual I, Set D, Q.2 (ix)1+1+1 = 3 marks
Compare the stability of primary, secondary, and tertiary carbocations, state the order of stability, and explain the reason for their relative stabilities.
Solution

Comparison. A carbocation is a carbon with three bonds and a positive charge. In a primary carbocation the positive carbon carries one alkyl group, in a secondary two and in a tertiary three. The more alkyl groups, the more stable the ion.

Tertiary, secondary, primary and methyl carbocations in order of decreasing stability.

Order of stability.

\text{tertiary }(3^\circ) \;>\; \text{secondary }(2^\circ) \;>\; \text{primary }(1^\circ)\;(>\;\ce{CH3+})

Reason. Alkyl groups are electron-releasing (+I inductive effect). They push electron density towards the positive carbon, which reduces and spreads out the positive charge; a dispersed charge is more stable. Three alkyl groups do this most. Hyperconjugation also helps: the C–H bonds next to \ce{C+} (9 in a tertiary, 6 in a secondary, 3 in a primary cation) share electron density with the empty 2p orbital.

2026 Annual I, Old syllabus (Curriculum 2006), MCQ 11, old syllabus1 mark
Which of the following is a tertiary alkyl halide?
  1. A\ce{CH3-CH2-Cl}
  2. B\ce{(CH3)3C-Br}Answer
  3. C\ce{CH3CHCl2}
  4. D\ce{CH3-CH2-CH2-Br}
Why

In \ce{(CH3)3C-Br} the carbon carrying Br is bonded to three other carbon atoms, so it is tertiary. Options A and D are primary; in \ce{CH3CHCl2} the chlorine-bearing carbon is bonded to only one carbon.

2026 Annual I, Old syllabus (Curriculum 2006), MCQ 12, old syllabus1 mark
Which of the following halides would react fastest in an \mathrm{S_N2} reaction?
  1. A\ce{CH3-Cl}Answer
  2. B\ce{(CH3)3C-Br}
  3. C\ce{(CH3)2CH-Cl}
  4. D\ce{C6H5-Br}
Why

\mathrm{S_N2} needs attack from the back of the carbon. Chloromethane has only small hydrogen atoms around its carbon, so it is the least hindered. The secondary halide is slower, the tertiary halide is too crowded, and bromobenzene does not undergo \mathrm{S_N2} (partial double bond).

2026 Annual I, Old syllabus (Curriculum 2006), Q.2 (vii), old syllabus1.5+1.5 = 3 marks
Why tertiary alkyl halides favor \mathrm{S_N1} mechanism, whereas primary alkyl halides favor \mathrm{S_N2} mechanism?
Solution
Tertiary alkyl halides favour \mathrm{S_N1} (1.5 marks)
  • Stable carbocation. Ionisation gives a tertiary carbocation, stabilised by the +I effect and hyperconjugation of three alkyl groups, so the slow ionisation step (\mathrm{S_N1}) happens easily.
  • Steric hindrance. Three bulky alkyl groups crowd the back of the C–X carbon, so a nucleophile cannot attack from the back; the one-step \mathrm{S_N2} route is blocked.
Primary alkyl halides favour \mathrm{S_N2} (1.5 marks)
  • Little steric hindrance. Only one alkyl group is on the C–X carbon, so the nucleophile easily attacks from the back and the substitution takes place in one step.
  • Unstable carbocation. A primary carbocation has only one electron-releasing group, so it is very unstable and the \mathrm{S_N1} ionisation is too slow.
\mathrm{S_N1}:\ 3^\circ>2^\circ>1^\circ\qquad\qquad\mathrm{S_N2}:\ 1^\circ>2^\circ>3^\circ

Exam focus

  1. \mathrm{S_N1} mechanism of tert-butyl bromide with water: carbocation, inductive effect, rate equation. (long)
    Asked as a 7-mark Section C question in 2026 (Set B Q.3 OR).
    Go to answer
  2. Why tertiary halides favour \mathrm{S_N1} and primary halides favour \mathrm{S_N2}. (short)
    Old-syllabus 2026 Q.2 (vii); needs steric hindrance and carbocation stability for each.
    Go to answer
  3. \mathrm{S_N2} mechanism with transition state, inversion and rate equation. (long)
    The partner of the \mathrm{S_N1} question; \mathrm{S_N2} appears in the book's key points and in MCQs every year.
    Go to answer
  4. Order of stability of carbocations and the reasons. (short)
    2026 Set D Q.2 (ix), 1 + 1 + 1 marks.
    Go to answer
  5. Retrosynthesis: the halogenoalkane that gives propan-2-ol or butan-2-ol. (short)
    Both 2026 new-syllabus sets asked this (Set B Q.2 (vii), Set D Q.2 (viii) OR).
    Go to answer
  6. Products with KCN, \ce{NH3}, aqueous \ce{OH-} and alcoholic \ce{OH-}. (mcq)
    Three 2026 MCQs came from this table (Set B MCQ 8 and 11, Set D MCQ 9).
    Go to answer
  7. Why chlorobenzene is less reactive than chloroethane towards nucleophiles. (short)
    SLO 2 of the unit and book exercise MCQ viii; draw the resonance structures.
    Go to answer
  8. Halogenation of benzene with a halogen carrier, with mechanism. (short)
    SLO 1 and three book exercise MCQs; write the catalyst over the arrow.
    Go to answer
  9. C–X bond strength and the silver nitrate test (colours of AgX). (short)
    SLO 7; a standard short question on reactivity order R–I > R–Br > R–Cl.
    Go to answer
  10. Substitution versus elimination and the Saytzeff rule. (short)
    Predicting the major product from conditions is an SLO and a frequent MCQ.
    Go to answer

Mark this unit as done to fill the Class 12 Chemistry ring.

Next, unit 10
Hydroxy compounds

© 2026 FBISE Fold. Independent study notes, not affiliated with the Federal Board of Intermediate and Secondary Education.